Joshua Graves
Exploring the Collision of Culture & Faith
Showdown (pt. 2)
December 16, 2009

The Bible knows of the human affection for showdowns.

After Jesus had already been born, pagan magicians came to one of the most powerful men in the world, Herod the Great (King Herod) and ask “Where is the one who has been born king of the Jews? We saw his star in the east and have come to worship him,” (Mt. 2:2).

To come to Herod’s palace inquiring as to the whereabouts of the king while in the current king’s presence was either an act of sheer stupidity or remarkable courage. Herod was the meanest man on the block.

  1. Herod was the extension of Caesar among the Jewish people in Israel.
  2. He died about the same time Jesus was born (perhaps even the same year).
  3. Herod was one of the wealthiest men on the planet. He built seven palaces during his lifetime. All of them  larger than the palaces of Caesar in Rome.
  4. Herod was the “Pantheon of bigness” (Eugene Peterson)—everything he did was over the top and extravagant.
    • Before he died he had an actual mountain built, from scratch, so that his body would rest in a palace that overlooked Jerusalem. Some believe that when Jesus tells his disciples that small faith can move “this mountain” he is directly referring to Herodium. Herodium is visible from the Mount of Olives.
    • Some scholars believe that Herod tried to rebuild the Temple to demonstrate his superiority over Solomon.
    • Caesarea was Herod’s tribute to Caesar—it boasted the largest harbor in the world (520 acres wide).
    • Herod built stadiums that rival any major college football stadium today. Herod was building NASCAR venues before NASCAR.
  5. Herod ruled by instilling fear through violence.
    • He once had the most talented citizens of Jericho assembled into a large stadium with instructions to soldiers that upon his death he wanted all of the innocent slaughtered so that all Israel would mourn Herod’s death.
    • He gave instructions, before embarking upon a long journey, that should he die he desired that his wife be killed lest she ever be with another man.
    • He killed one mother-in-law (ten wives might sound that bad, but ten mothers-in-law), an uncle, and three sons.
    • Caesar Augustus famously remarked, “I’d rather be Herod’s pig than his son.”

Pagan magicians walk into King Herod’s presence and ask, “Where’s the king, we think he’s already among us.” That Herod did not execute them on the spot is a testament to how much more concerned Herod is with the threat that Jesus poses to his rule. A threat most contemporary Christians have never spent a minute mulling over.

“All Jerusalem” is disturbed because Jerusalem is full of mini-Herods; the powerbrokers and    chief players. Herod calls together all of the experts he can summon for a conference call. “I need to know, I must know where the anointed one {“Christ”} was to be born.” The experts give the correct answer, “Bethlehem,” and do the religious thing—they support their answer with a text!

Herod brings back the magicians in secret, presumably because he’s afraid, and attempts to strike an alliance with these outsiders. The irony is thick. The pagan magicians want to worship Jesus. The orthodox Jews and Herod want him eliminated. Herod gives the magicians a game-plan. “Find the baby, let me know, for I too desire to worship.”

I’d love to have been privy to the conversation among the Magi as they left Herod’s palace. Do you think for one minute they were fooled by Herod’s sudden piety? If these men could interpret the stars, I think they could see through a power-hungry despot.

The Magi went on their way, searching for the anointed one. They say the star. Perhaps it was Haley’s comet. Perhaps it was a supernova. Perhaps it was Jupiter and Saturn (two important planets in Roman and Jewish astronomy). In the ancient world, one could not separate creation from humanity. “A remarkable event with the planets meant something remarkable on earth,” (N.T. Wright paraphrase).

The Magi find the young boy. After a long journey, how good they must have felt. The lavished the boy with gifts, they bowed down and paid homage to the one they called king. Having been warned in a dream, they intentionally dismiss Herod’s order and return to their home land via a different route.

The first humans to greet God in the flesh are not Caesars, Kings, or Herods—but magicians.

Labels: Advent
6 Comments

Thanks for the insights, Josh. The subversive nature of Jesus’ very appearance on earth, much less his life and death, is an overlooked facet of the Birth Narrative.

There is a great deal of courage in the Magi. I wonder if I would have the same courage they did.

by Trey (Dec 16 2009, 10:08 am)

Actually it appears to be the shepherds who were the first humans (other than Joseph and Mary) to see the baby Jesus (Luke 2). It seems that they found out about him on the very day he was born, and saw him before eight days had passed, if not the same day. The wise men didn’t even arrive in Jerusalem until after Jesus was born, and then took additional time to travel to Bethlehem (Matthew 2). However, that doesn’t detract from the points you made in your post.

by rjohns (Dec 24 2009, 1:11 pm)

I was reading the Matthew story by itself.

by josh (Dec 25 2009, 4:53 pm)

I think it’s important to read the narratives as stand alone texts before we read them together.

THanks for the post.

by josh (Dec 25 2009, 4:55 pm)

Certainly, and thanks for the response!

What do you think really happened, then? If both accounts (i.e. Matthew and Luke) are accurate, then it would appear that the shepherds really did arrive first, and then the magi some time later, and the two accounts are simply emphasizing different facts surrounding the same event. And if the same Holy Spirit was behind both human authors of the text, wouldn’t that perhaps suggest that the author of Matthew is not trying to imply that the magi were there first?

Maybe the significance of their visit lies elsewhere, in some other aspect of their visit, such as the symbolism of the gifts they bring? There could be several meanings to be derived from their visit, but if both Luke and Matthew are accurate, then surely the magi being there first is not one of those meanings, else we would be reading a contradiction into the text.

by rjohns (Dec 26 2009, 6:14 am)

And also…I hope you had a happy Christmas!

by rjohns (Dec 26 2009, 6:39 am)
Post a Comment

Join in the dialogue. Required fields are marked *

*
*
Read My BlogAbout The BookSee The FilmWritings and Other ResourcesAbout the AuthorAdditional Links